[Editor's note - I wrote this over a year ago for the amusement of my friends. With Christmas approaching I thought I would post it here for posterity.]
Over the years I have made some observations about the art and practice of giving gifts to children other than one's own. It seems that such situations allow many people to let out their inner sadist and take out whatever repressed rage they have built up on the recipient's parents. They may act like they don't know that's what they're doing, but you'd have to be really stupid to not understand the impact of your gifts on the household being so afflicted. This is especially true when such gifts come from other parents. They know what they're doing, and unless revenge for prior gifts is their motive, there is no excuse or explanation other than outright hostility toward the target's, er, recipient's parents. Perhaps you should re-evaluate your relationship with such people.
So, as a guideline from one parent to those of you who have the opportunity now or in the future to give gifts to the children of others I offer the following list of gift-giving guidelines.
1) Do not give anything you're not willing to get back as a reciprocal gift - This can be considered the "Golden Rule" of gift giving, and if it is followed, then for the most part the rest of the rules will happen naturally. If you decide to give little Timmy bongos for his third birthday, then when your child's next birthday comes up, don't be surprised if Timmy's parents reward your child with some sort of percussion instrument (or complete drum kit if they're a teen). And when that happens, just remember - you asked for it. This can be especially dangerous between two sets of parents, because it can lead to brinksmanship of the most dangerous kind ("They gave Jessica that damned kazoo for her birthday, so I say we give their little Clarence a trumpet").
2) Do not give gifts with thousands of small parts - Legos sure are fun...until you've stepped on your fiftieth one in bare feet. Legos, Tinker Toys, Lincoln Logs, Lite Brites, jigsaw puzzles, marbles, beads, most board and card games and myriad other gifts are of a "play once, lose forever" nature. Unless the child has OCD the pieces will never all be put back in the same place, ever again (unless the parents do it, and frankly that just isn't going to happen - we're too busy making sure the kids don't self-immolate). So instead the parts and pieces just float around the house, turning up in the damnedest places (like under your stockinged foot). They exhibit a self-mobile migratory capability that is somewhat scary. We are still vacuuming up pieces from gifts that are four or five years old. These are classic candidates for the "Mommy and Daddy are putting this gift up to save it for you because it's special" category - which then engenders arguments with the kids when they pester to have the gift gotten down so they can play with it - "We'll pick it up, we promise!" Just say no.
3) Do not give gifts with "some assembly required" - Unless you're willing to do the assembly yourself, be prepared to stop over some time in the future and see the gift still in pieces, strewn all over the playroom, and with some of the pieces broken and pitched or vacuumed, so that it can never be assembled. If you want to give Barbie's Modern Kitchen or Batman's Secret Headquarters as a gift, fine - just put it together first before bringing it over, or be the cool uncle or friend of the family and help the kid put it together right when you give it to them. Otherwise, please abstain.
4) Do not give electronic gifts that make noise - I repeat, "Do not give electronic gifts that make noise". If you feel the need to violate this precept, then at least make sure that as many of the following are applicable:
a) The device can be given an emergency batterectomy in the field with no special tools.
b) The device has a headphone jack with which to restrict its squalling to the ears of the victim, er, child.
c) The device CAN BE SHUT OFF. NEVER, EVER, EVER, EVER, EVER, EVER GIVE GIFTS THAT MAKE NOISE SIMPLY BY BEING TOUCHED OR DETECTING MOTION. If you ever want to be scared out of your wits, try walking through a darkened playroom after the kids are in bed and have Big Bird suddenly emit his slightly psycho laugh in the dark because some other toy in the toy box shifted and pressed against his tummy.
5) Do not give gifts beyond the child's age with the instruction "this is for when they're older" - If that's the case then give it to them when they're older (does that not seem obvious?). Otherwise it's just one more damned thing for the receiving family to store, look after, clean and ultimately remember that they have and pull it out of storage at the appropriate time. In addition, please be aware not only of the suggested age range on the packaging, but of the actual emotional and psychological age of the recipient and adjust accordingly. Something suitable for an average four year old may not be suitable for a four year old with ADHD and anger control issues.
6) Do not give gifts that make a mess - This may really seem curmudgeonly because paints, clay and Play-Doh, "goo", Easy Bake ovens and all that may look like great fun, and gosh, they are great fun - for the kids. For the people whose house they are unleashed in, they are simply a cleaning nightmare (no matter how "water soluble" the item says it is, it isn't - there's "water soluble" paint permanently stained into our carpet). If you want the kids to play with such things then have them ready at your house for when they come to visit. Enjoy!
7) Do not give gifts that are alive - Unless you're willing to pay the vet bills and take care of them whenever the family feels the need to leave for a weekend, week or month, pets are best left as a decision of the parents, no matter how much you think "The kids are really ready for a dog (cat, fish, gerbil, bird, snake or whatever)". Also be prepared to be the person who has to explain to the child(ren) about death when said live gift stops being live.
8) Do not give gifts that promote intra-sibling rivalry - If you give a super-really-neato gift to one and not another then you have just unleashed an ongoing struggle over that gift that will not stop until:
a) one of the children dies, possibly in a fight over the gift,
b) the gift is broken, possibly in a fight over the gift, or,
c) the gift is removed from the scene (typically at night after bedtime, and hence becomes "lost" in parental speak) and put in storage or thrown away by the parents in a vain attempt to bring peace to the valley.
9) Do not give gifts that promote intra-sibling violence - Need I say that gifts that look like toy weapons will cause the kids to use them as real weapons? Hence play swords, spears, bows and arrows and guns will all be used as swords, spears, bows and arrows and guns on the nearest target, typically a sibling or a pet or possibly a parent (although that will only happen once before the item is then sent to the "Island of Misfit Toys", my term, a la the Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer cartoon, for the large tub in the garage that used to hold such problem gifts).
10) Do not give gifts that require the whole family present to use - Oh, sure, in you're head you're thinking, "This will be great for them, and will foster 'family nights' and all sorts of cheerful togetherness." Instead, you've just sentenced the parents to either endless fighting with the kids over why tonight is (again) not the right night to get out that gift and play with it, or to succumbing to a grumbling round of play while having other things (like bills, laundry, dinner, housecleaning) not get done instead. Either way you've increased the parents' stress levels, and unless you're actually a hateful person and that was your intention, it's better if you gave things that allow the child to be "self-amusing" (which is the greatest gift of love - at least for the parents).